Too much damping material like sheep wool, mineral wool, cotton, polyester fiber, can be problematic in a speaker enclosure, due to following reasons:
1. Reducing Air Pressure & Driver Compliance
- Speaker drivers and speaker enclosures are designed to work within a specific air pressure environment inside the enclosure. If you add too much damping material, especially materials that absorb sound and "fill up" the space inside, it reduces the volume of air that the driver can move.
- This reduces the effective volume of the enclosure and can alter the system's tuning (especially in relation to the driver's compliance and the box's resonance). In turn, this can lower the efficiency of the system and lead to a less accurate or less controlled bass response.
2. Absorption of Low-Frequency Energy
- Too much damping material can excessively absorb low-frequency energy. While controlling low-frequency reflections is important, if you overly dampen the enclosure, the speaker may lose its ability to radiate bass properly.
- This leads to a reduced bass response and potentially a "muddy" sound due to insufficient energy transfer from the driver to the air in the room.
3. Impact on Transient Response
- Too much damping can over-control the driver's movement, potentially resulting in a slower transient response. This can lead to less precise bass and midrange reproduction, affecting the clarity and realism of the sound.
4. Too little reflection from inside the speaker cabinet can reduce the spatial sound image
- Internal reflections do need to be controlled, but some reduced reflections are desirable to maintain a natural sound within the box and can subtly influence the tonal balance of the sound. A completely damped box can produce a loss of vibrancy and over-damping of midrange frequencies, leading to a "flat" , inert or overly controlled sound.
- These reflections inside enclosure can escape through the speaker cone (especially for midrange drivers) and blend with the direct sound. If there are too few reflections due to excessive absorption, the energy of certain frequencies may be reduced, leading to a "dry" or overly dampened sound that lacks a sense of space and presence. Reflections inside the cabinet can indirectly positively influence spatial imaging,
In Summary:
- While some internal reflections are necessary for a natural and spatial sound, too much uncontrolled reflection can cause resonances, standing waves, or coloration that muddle the sound. Reflections inside the speaker box influence the frequency response of the speaker. If there are resonances or standing waves due to reflections, they can cause peaks or dips in the frequency response, especially in the midrange and bass regions. This can lead to a coloration of sound, making certain frequencies more pronounced or suppressed, make distortions and blur the clarity of sound. This is why a balanced amount of damping material is critical — it should manage the reflections without eliminating them entirely.
- In an ideal speaker, the sound that comes directly from the driver should dominate, while reflections (from the cabinet or the room) should be minimized or delayed enough not to interfere with the perception of directionality, but to keep the spaciousness of the sound. Of course, room reflections have dominant influence to perception of spatial sound, depth, and width of the soundstage because they add complex delay patterns, phase shifts, and reverberation effects that give spatial cues.
- Goal: Control internal reflections and standing waves inside the enclosure without excessively dampening low-frequency energy or altering the driver's performance.
- Optimal damping: Helps to reduce unwanted reflections, but maintaining a balance is key to ensuring the speaker has the right resonance and sound characteristics.
In essence, the aim is not to eliminate all radiation inside the box, but to control undesirable reflections and prevent resonances that would interfere with the driver’s performance. Moderation and strategic placement of damping materials are key to achieving this balance.
How much damping material should be placed in a sealed enclosure?
A starting estimate is around 30-35g per liter of air volume inside woofer cabinet and 35-40g for midrange cabinet. For example, for a sealed speaker with an internal air volume of 30 liters, you would need for start approximately 900g of damping material, such as sheep wool. Perform an initial listening test. Then, adjust the amount by adding or removing 50g at a time and continue with listening tests until you achieve the optimal sound.
Using too little damping material in the speaker cabinet often results in an overwhelming, slightly resonant sound, where certain frequencies can dominate and create imbalance.
On the other hand, using too much damping material tends to make the sound overly constrained, reducing its power and impact. The audio becomes more localized around the speakers, failing to fill the room with a rich, immersive experience.
With the optimal amount of wool, the sound achieves a perfect balance—powerful and room-filling, yet natural and lively. It avoids being overly damped or overwhelming, providing an engaging and dynamic listening experience.Tihomir Haralović, M.Sc. in Physics
Zagreb, 26 December 2024